Jean-François Esculier, one of the world leaders in new trends in the prevention of running injuries recently presented some of the latest research regarding footwear. This has completely changed the way we think about and prescribe footwear.
We recommend running in minimalist shoes (in other words, simple, low shoes that allow better contact with the ground), for several reasons:
As part of a study led by researchers from Laval University, 42 experts from 11 countries defined minimalist shoes and built the Minimalist Index (MI). Minimalist shoes are footwear providing minimal interference with the natural movement of the foot. For example, some Vibram Five-Finger models show MI scores close to 100%. In contrast, ultra-maximalist shoes, such as some Hoka models, have an MI closer to 0%.
The level of minimalism of running shoes can be rated with a scale that considers five characteristics:
Consider the Minimalist Index to plan your transition. Switching from one model to another may lead to injury when done too quickly.
Runners should aim for 1 month of transition time for every 10% change in the Minimalist Index score. For example, you should plan a two-month transition period when switching from shoes rated 50% to others rated 70%.
Depending on your habits and your tolerance to change, you may require more time or even less time to transition. Too quick of a transition towards a more minimalist shoe (higher score on the MI) will typically result in symptoms to your foot, Achilles tendon or calf muscle. Equally, too quick of a transition towards a more maximalist shoe (lower score on the MI) will typically cause symptoms to your knee, hip or lower back, simply because different shoes load different tissues of your body differently.
In the end, everything is a matter of adaptation! Listen to your body!
The elements that are essential in selecting a pair of shoes for children are relatively straightforward and widely accepted by all experts in this field.
Furthermore, there is no age when the child/teenager should start wearing maximalist running shoes (cushioned, elevated heel, relatively rigid). However, if a teenager has already grown accustomed to maximalist running shoes, there should be a progressive transition to minimalist shoes spread over a few weeks in order to allow the foot to adapt
Beginners with no running experience (or have not run for more than 12months) are “virgins” in terms of their own biomechanical learning curve. It is therefore important to integrate as early as possible shoes that interfere as little as possible with natural biomechanics as well as with the development of the feet.
Minimalist running shoes will help runners develop more efficient impact-moderating behaviours. In other words, they will learn to run light.
80% of injuries are caused by mechanical overload from a change of habit. The best way to prevent injuries is the quantification of mechanical stress. Footwear and biomechanics are only a small part of the puzzle.
We are in a society driven by marketing and non-clinical logical or scientific research. The research and development departments of the companies only offer the glitz. Most importantly, no clinical studies justify the use of these technologies.
It is important to understand that some new technologies proposed every year by companies may have no scientific basis and are designed for a simple objective, that is, to sell specific products.
In the absence of scientific proof of the protective aspect of modern shoes and in light of the indirect evidence of their probable detrimental effect, consider entrusting your body to what nature intended and run barefoot. If weather, running surfaces, or the social environment prevents you from doing so, opt for the minimalist approach.
Any change in your training program, if too significant, entails the risk of overloading tissues and therefore causing injury. A change in shoe must be done as gradually as a change in volume of training and will affect everyone in different ways. To ensure this progression and for personalised tips, give the team here a shout. and always remember to listen to your body first!
December 23, 2020
September 18, 2019
March 27, 2019
March 22, 2019